i don't usually use eyeliner, but i needed it for a makeup look i was trying out and thought i'd try this one since i'd heard such nice things. i was super impressed with it!

it applies very smoothly and the thin brush makes it easy to trail out for beginners. it's very pigmented and long-lasting, and easily removed with makeup remover at the end of the day. i removed a star though, as rubbing it hard enough can cause it to flake a bit, and sometimes the color can become uneven if you trail over it again with the brush. still a really great value for the price.