Firstly, I like that the shader side is thinner than the highlighter side, it makes it very functional. I got this is White, and the highlight was nice but I wouldn't recommend it to people looking for a really subtle, natural highlight. But the big thing that got me is I live in a colder climate, and the highlighter side product stick actually snapped! It's futher down into the tub, so it's still useable, but it makes me think maybe this product isn't made so much for cold climates.