Let me tell you how this is the best mascara ever. I bought it in ash, just because I wanted a waterproof mascara but ever since I started wearing it I've gotten so many compliments and I bought one like 2 months ago and I'm still using the same one, everyday. So it doesn't only last a long time but also very good and doesn't smudge when keeping it all day, it only does when applying but you can clean it up with an oil cleanser and a q-tip.  Also YOU HAVE TO USE AN OIL CLEANSER, since it's waterproof, I made a mistake of not doing it first time I applied.