I was always bad at drawing eyeliner on my thin and oily eyelids with a pencil type eyeliner. Sometimes even with brush type liners the line smudged and was not beautiful enough. Until I discovered this liner! I bought this because of the price, I originally planned to buy another one. Now this is my HG!! I love the brown color, it is easy to apply and super long lasting and smudge proof and water proof!! :)