I'm pretty fair, so I got #5 Sugar Brown because I've read many reviews about how this is a nice contour shade. It is nice for very, very light contouring -- it's a light brown, doesn't pull orange, and you can't over-do it. The swatch picture below was taken with flash, and you can barely see the swatch (it's only slightly darker than my skin tone). I would like it for every day use, but this is not matte. It has a very slight splash of glitter throughout, and it is definitely noticeable in the face more-so than in the pan.