It's awful! Don't believe the hype surrounding this mascara. I bought because all the korean youtubers were promoting it and I was super excited, but it turned out to be crap. The mascara is really sticky and clumpy. Makes me non-existent lashes look shorter. Does not give a nice finish at all. The only good thing is that the color is noticeable and nice. I don't know if it's suppose to be waterproof, but even with oil it was so hard to remove. I had so many eyelashes fall off from trying to remove it.