I really appreciated this product mainly because I feel like it really cleansed my skin. It did not make my face feel really tight after usage. I really didn't like it when I was wearing make up because I felt like it didn't take it off as I would like. If I used this in conjunction with an oil cleanser I felt like it did a better job. It was nice to try it but I don't feel like I like it over some of my other cleansers.