I've used rice one and it was good. I mean nothing spectacular but it cleaned my face well. Skin was clean with this squeaking feeling which I like :D My skin has tendency to get dry but it didn't when I used this foam. However it didn't brighten my skin at all (I didn't expect it but still it's what they say it does). And the smell is kinda.. It's nice but strong so I liked it at first but then it started to irritate me a bit