I do not know why people rave about this product.

I did not feel the rose smell or anything, I did not see the effect.

It is like the normal one, I ordered the gold one from secret key, but I felt like the gold one was more special than the Rose edition.

It is a good dupe to the Missha one, it is like a high quality water for me haha!

But, maybe in the future, I might come back to it.. I've only used it for 10 days!