I ordered the Elf Light Rose and I absolutely love the color!!! The color is what's shown in the peripera lip swatches and it's great if you're going for a more natural look but still want a pop of color! As the name implies, this formula is way lighter than the original velvet line but I also think a catch to that is because the formula is lighter the tint doesn't last as long as the original velvets. The tint definitely comes off a lot easier/faster when you eat, but hey that's something a touch up can fix! ;)