This was an okay makeup remover for lip and eye makeup, but the main problem is that it needs a ton of product for each use. I'd tried using less product before, but it really didn't do well removing makeup (especially without tugging at my eyes) unless I used more product. Part of the problem is that the stopper on the bottle only lets a small amount of product through at a time, thus encouraging you to use more product overall. I ended up deciding to just use this as a lip makeup remover, since it does a decent job removing hard to remove lip products without needing as much product overall. I'm glad I was able to find a way to use this product without being wasteful, but it requires so much product per application that this ends up being a really expensive product overall, so I won't be repurchasing it.