Bought in brown and is my favorite eyeliner out of the dozen that I've ever tried. I used to use black more often but brown tends to give a softer look. Pigmentation isn't super dense so it's easy to go over the same line a few times and not have it smudge and still get the level of darkness or lightness that you want. My only complaint is that after about four-five months, the pen outside itself starts to chip? It seems like the coloring/plastic/paint of the Clio label begins to chip away and sometimes come off on my hands while I'm using it so I have to wash my hands before I get it stuck on my face. It's the only eyeliner I use that doesn't smudge on my lower eye! Very glad and this is my second one, will be trying others soon :)