Eyeliner gives of the color very easily and very opaque. However, it does smudge on my lower eyelids which is why I will not buy this again, I’m still in search for an eyeliner that does not smudge :) lastly, I did not know this at first, but apparently you can just sharpen this pencil with a normal pencil sharpener. Although it’s a non-wooden pencil you can still sharpen it like a normal wooden pencil.