This is my cleanser balm type so I can not compare with others, but I liked it a lot, it removes even the most difficult makeup.... is impressive, I bought it because I do not want to put too much force in my eyes when I remove the mascara, and this product is perfect for that, it has a very noticeable smell but that does not matter to me, it leaves the face clean, I would buy it again for sure ... and also comes a lot of product and the packaging is beautiful!!!