This is my third oil/balm cleanser and I really like this one. I like that it is liquid on room temperature it makes it a lot easier to use in my opinion. It has a nice, subtle scent, which is not irritating for me, the scent makes my night-time routine so relaxing. I use sunscreen and bb cream, mascara everyday and this cleanser easily removes them. Waterproof eyeliner is not so easy to remove, but I only use that on special occasions so this is not a problem for me.