I have mix feelings about this mascara. Pro: 1. I like the size and shape of the brush, comfortable to work with. 2. I didn't like the color of the mascara first, it seemed too light and too reddish, but when I apply 2-3 coats it looks great, it appears dark brown. 3. Easy to remove with oil clanser. (4. The tube has a lovely color.) Con: 1. The texture of the mascara is too thin, 1 coat is invisible, when I apply 2-3 coats the color and lenght is nice, but it doesn't give any volume. 2. The application is so messy because of it's thin texture.