So far this oil cleanser works the best for me. It's great for "gritting" and it takes off my waterproof mascara so quickly and completely. It washes off really easily as well. The only complaint is that its quite perfumed, I personally don't have a sensitivity to perfume (so be warned, to those who do) but i hate it when it accidentally gets into the mouth, it has such a strong smell/taste. I kind of like the smell, just not when it's in my mouth.