I really like this mascara. I have short, sparse lashes that are pin straght and look down. This mascara hold curl really well. However, it is not smudge proof. I really like the color, which is reddish brown. It can be a bit clumpy, but that maybe because i apply A LOT of layers to maximize whatever lashes i have. In terms of volume and length it does pretty good job. I already repurchased it multiple times.