I'm not a fan of the fake apple candy scent, and the performance is so-so. It removes most of my makeup but still leaves some traces of eye makeup. It rinses off mostly clean but I feel like I definitely need to second cleanse afterwards. Honestly it's not bad but a bit disappointing considering the hype. I've used better oil cleansers so this is only decent for me. I would have given this 4 stars before using the jamong cleansing balm which is my HG!