Usually, every single gel liner i have ever tried have failed me because i dont know maybe i have oily eye area or weird eye shape. IDK. When i read all the raving reviews, i thought, maybe i can finally wear a gel liner that will not smudge or wear off or leave mark under my eye. But i was met with disappointment when i tried this. this is like all the other gel liner. and i am upset :/ but its a good looking product so i gave it to my friend.