I bought the shade #13, which I thought would be a dusty, slightly dark dried rose colour. When I swatch it it looks that way, but on my lips the colour is lighter, almost like a mute pink. It's not bad but I prefer darker colours, which is why I took off a star. The formula dries quickly and doesn't budge, but it settles into the lines of your lips more noticeably than other tints. Also, it has a very prominent scent. I don't dislike it but I haven't been able to place it yet (although it does remind me of Jolly Ranchers or some other candy). All in all this product isn't my favourite tint but I will continue to use it.