I got both of them. Both are pretty pigmented and easy to remove. Didn't hurt my eyes nor my eyelashes.

#1 Volume

I love this one. It does give volume to my eyelashes and makes my eyes look bigger but I think the wand is too big for under eyelashes.

Overall I give it: 5/5 stars.

#2 Curling

This one doesn't mantain the curling effect it claims to give but the wand is thin enough for under eyelashes.

Overall I give it: 4/5 stars.

I might repurchase the volume one.