I was debating between #6 and #8 but all the Youtube videos that I watched heavily recommended #8 so I went with it. I am glad I got #8! It is such a pretty color and reminds me of the NYX Lip Lingerie #17 (Seduction) which I really love. I love that this looks nicely even on chapped lips.. although it can feel a little dry some time after application. I feel that the tint lasts pretty well--I can still notice the color after drinking/eating.