This was my first lip tint from Etude House and I'm not sure how I feel about it. Like the name of this product, it is a water lip tint and it smells like orange jelly. However, the pigmentation of this does need to be reapplied several times to get color. The color does go away as soon as food or contact with water is there though. Therefore I'm not sure if this product is good for people who wouldn't like to retouch, which is personally why I like lip tints (no retouching), but this product does need LOTS of retouching.