I got this for my mom. She rarely complains about a k-beauty product but this time she totally hated this one.

She says it is not blue at all, it looks black with blue undertone. It also hurt her eyes to the point they get watery (her eyes are not that sensitive).

I have used the brown one before and I did like the color but the formula was too dry and had some fall outs.

The only "good" thing about this mascara is that it is waterproof and smudge-proof.