i purchased this tint in #1 Garden Balsam. the color is very beautiful! the consistency of the tint is nice and i thought it would be moisturizing, but my lips are always dry regardless of what i use on them and this tint accentuated that. :-( it might perform better if used with a balm or gloss, but that also will hurt the staying power. it has a very strong scent of rose, which i don't mind, but you may want to be careful if you're sensitive to fragrance.
this is a lovely tint though, so i'd like to give it another try if my lips ever behave for me. if you're curious and have lips that aren't a constant mess, i'd say go for it!