I got no. 3 orange cookie and I think the pictures are pretty accurate of what the color is like in real life. Packaging is pretty too--it reminds me of the 3CE matte lipsticks (but this is better-priced). I didn't give this 5 stars because I honestly had such high expectations for peripera and it fell short. I prefer the airy ink velvet compared to this stick version. I love matte lipsticks but this formula just doesn't stick that well on my lips, which tend to be a little bit more on the dry side but not crazy dry. Pigmentation is good though.