So I really like this toner, like how to feels on my skin, the smell well I don't notice a smell at all, I have very oily tzone and dry cheek and 44 years old skin that only recently been taken care of. My cheek fe hydrated and it is nice to had my serum on top of it,  not tacky at all.  will probably buy it again but I want to try the Instree Green tea toner though and compare. I don't wear makeup either.