I rate it 2 stars mainly because this product doesn't work very well on me. I have combination skin but more towards oily. Whenever I use the aritaum idol waterproof pencil, it smudges easily on my lids even when I use an eyelid primer beforehand. Also, removing this product takes a long time and lots of steps to remove the product from my eyes. The product doesn't cause irritation at all, but if you don't remove the product properly, the product transfers and again smudges all over your eyes til the next morning. Wouldn't recommend this product for those with oily eyelids like mine.

Though the product itself is great. It glides on very well on the eyes, great pigmentation, and draws smoothly and nicely on the eyes.