This is a nice, rich black eyeliner, easy to apply and long-lasting. It's probably the thinnest eyeliner pencil I've seen, great for making extremely skinny, precise, almost invisible lines. I don't mind if people can see that I'm wearing eyeliner, so I will probably not need such a skinny pencil in the future, but it is a great, subtle eyeliner and I recommend it! Be aware, though, that the pencil is really tiny, so you aren't getting much for the price. The photo shows this pencil next to the Etude House Proof 10 pencil for size comparison.