I ordered the plum color which is absolutely gorgeous. The cokiur stays for about 5-6 hours without smudging and is decently waterproof. The HUGE downside to this product is it is so unbelievably STICKY. It never dries. I have very deep eye creases and I literally had to go home from school and wash the makeup off because I couldn't stand the two parts of my eyelid in the crease sticking together. If you dont have large eye creases or plan to use the product as a liner I reccomend it. But if you have deep set eyes and are planning on wearing it as a general shadow, I wouldn't recommend it.