I really like how natural this eyebrow pencil looks. I purchased it in brown. It's very light so you need to draw over your eyebrows several times, but the result is soft and natural looking eyebrows. The only problem I have is that the spoolie part fell out of the bottom and I can't attach it back so I have to use them separately which is a bit inconvenient. I don't use the sponge part because I don't think it's necessary but it's nice to have. It's also a bit difficult to take the end out and change between the spoolie and sponge parts (that's how I broke mine)! Overall though, I love using it!