I have mixed feelings about this mascara cause I love the brown natural eye lash look it gives me, but it's almost impossible to remove. I've tried make up wipes and a couple of removers (also oil-based), but none of them could remove the mascara completely. Even after removing the mascara, I still have clumps of it on my lashes, which seem to have dried and got permanently stuck. Also my eyes get irritated from having to rub them so much to remove the mascara. I guess I'll keep trying to use it from time to time cause I love the look, but I'm still on the lookout for the perfect brown mascara.