I would give this product a 3.5 stars.  You get quite a bit of product which is nice.  The scent is quite powerful and smells like Vics Vaporub.  It does go away eventually.  It absorbs well and keeps my face moisturized.  I only use this at night.  It doesn't feel tacky when I touch my face after application.  I do think it brightens my face a bit, but not sure if I would repurchase it.  It's been over a month since my purchase but I still have a lot of product left in the jar.